Barney's primary purpose is to provide academic services to
faculty and students. These services include e-mail, software
requested by the faculty (e.g., statistics packages, engineering
software, etc.), the Usenet newsfeed, listservs, and beginning in May
of 1997, student web pages. These services are available to all
faculty and students currently working at or attending Gonzaga. This
document will describe what specific services the faculty have
available to them for their classes.
There are two specific services that are available to faculty for
disseminating information to and between students. These are
listservs and Usenet news.
Mailing Lists (listservs)
Listservs are mailing distribution lists. When someone mails to
the listserv's address, the message is resent to everyone that is
"subscribed" to that listserv. The number of subscribers to a list
can range anywhere from one person to hundreds of thousands. The
listserv software on Barney is meant to handle smaller lists
(<1000 subscribers) such as classes, academic discussion lists,
etc.
The primary benefit of listservs is that the message is sent
directly to the subscriber's e-mail address. This ensures that each
and every subscriber receives the message as long as they check their
e-mail. It also makes it easy for the person to respond back to the
list or the original sender because the message is no different than
any other e-mail message. With the added benefit of users being able
to subscribe or unsubscribe from the list whenever they choose, using
a listserv is an easy and flexible way to distribute information to
students in a class, colleagues, etc.
There are only a few drawbacks of using listservs over other
methods for distributing information. The first is that a copy of the
message is sent to each and every subscriber. This can result in
significant disk space consumption if there are a lot of subscribers
on a single server (i.e., Barney) or if there are a lot of documents
or files passed back and forth over the list. Another minor
inconvenience is that many mail packages don't thread mail messages
making a conversation slightly more difficult to follow. Finally,
there is no automatic archiving of messages sent to the list; the
individual subscribers are responsible for keeping any messages they
want to keep.
Listserv services are available on Barney for faculty, staff, and student groups. To request that a list be created on Barney, browse to http://barney.gonzaga.edu/tech/listrequest.html.
Newsgroups (Usenet)
Messages posted to newsgroups are not distributed to individuals
the same way they are with mailing lists. A message that is sent to a
newsgroup is referred to as an article and is posted to an NNTP
server. The NNTP server then transfers the article to other NNTP
servers that it is connected which then forward them to other NNTP
servers and so on until the article is distributed to all of the NNTP
servers on the Internet (thousands) that 'carry' the newsgroup where
the article was posted. There are more than 30,000 public newsgroups
of which Gonzaga's NNTP server (news.gonzaga.edu) carries about
15,00. In addition a server can have private newsgroups that are not
distributed outside of the local NNTP server. Gonzaga currently has
fifteen private newsgroups for class use, announcements, computer
help, etc.
There are several advantages of newsgroups over mailing lists and
several disadvantages as well. The two primary benefits of newsgroups
are that most newsreaders automatically thread the messages to
simplify reading of prolonged discussions and that the messages are
archived for the entire semester. Also, newsgroups require a lot less
disk space since only one copy of the article is stored on each
server. For a private group, the article is only stored once.
There are a number of disadvantages to using newsgroups that make
them unsuitable for many purposes. The primary disadvantage is that
the user needs to go and get the article rather than having the
message mailed directly to them. Second, off-campus students may have
some difficulty getting to Barney to read the newsgroups, especially
if they have an account on AOL or some other online service that
connects to the Internet. Finally, the newsreader (slrn on Barney,
tin on Betty) can be somewhat cumbersome to learn.
To create a newsgroup for a class or club, contact
.
Summary
As a rule of thumb when deciding whether to use a newsgroup or a
mailing list, consider the audience. If you have a specific audience,
their e-mail addresses are readily available, and they want to
receive all of the messages, then a mailing list is probably the
better choice. If your audience is broad, the users are difficult to
identify, or the amount of traffic is high, then a newsgroup might be
the better choice. The following list of features may be helpful for
those trying to decide whether to use a mailing list or
newsgroup.
|
|
|
|
|
Messages are sent directly to the user's mailbox |
|
|
|
Messages can be read by users on AOL, Prodigy, etc. |
|
|
|
Messages are archived for later reading |
|
|
|
Messages are available for browsing by unsubscribed users |
|
|
|
Messages can be moderated prior to sending |
|
|
|
User can reply to listserv/newsgroup and/or original poster |
|
|
|
Able to restrict which users can read the messages |
|
|
|
Able to read messages along path of conversation (threaded) |
|
|
Any questions or requests for additional services should be
directed to
.